When Was Interest Rate Risk Dropped from U.S. Bank Capital Requirements?

With The Final Rule Implementing Basel I in 1989

Commercial banks and bank holding companies in the United States are subject to risk-based capital requirements. The capital metrics are calculated as the ratio of a measure of the bank’s equity to risk-weighted assets. To calculate risk-weighted assets, each type of asset is multiplied by a factor that is increasing in the credit risk of the asset, and then the types are added up. For example, a small business loan is given a weight of 100 percent while a Treasury security is given a weight of zero.

U.S. risk-based capital metrics used to capture interest rate risk as well as credit risk. Interest rate risk is the possibility that the value of a fixed-rate term security or loan will decline in value because interest rates rise. For example, the capital guidepost in the Federal Reserve Board’s “Form for Analyzing Bank Capital” (ABC) developed in the mid-1950s included capital benchmarks that increased with the maturity of Treasury securities.[1] The form was used at least until the mid-1970s. A bank was expected to fund with equity 0 percent of Treasury bills with maturities up to one year, 0.5 percent of Treasury notes with one- to five-year maturities, 4 percent of Treasury securities with five- to 10-year maturities, and 6 percent of Treasury securities with maturities greater than 10 years.

In the second half of the 1980s, the Fed proposed two risk-based capital guidelines that were somewhat sensitive to interest rate risk.[2] Neither proposal was finalized. In 1986, the Federal Reserve, OCC and FDIC proposed a capital measure that applied a risk weight of 0 to Treasury securities with remaining maturities of one year or less and 30 percent for longer-term Treasury securities.[3] In 1987, the Fed proposed a new metric developed with the OCC, FDIC and Bank of England.[4] The measure applied a 10 percent risk weight to short-term (one year or less) Treasuries and a 25 percent weight on longer-term Treasuries.[5]

Interest rate risk was dropped from consideration in risk-weighted capital requirements with the Basel Accord, now called the Basel I capital agreement. The Basel I standard was proposed in a December 1987 “consultative paper.”[6] The paper notes that the Basel Committee considered incorporating interest rate risk into the risk weights, but “[a]ll members agreed, however, that interest rate risk generally required further study…” The Committee proposed that all domestic central government securities, regardless of maturity, receive a risk weight of zero, and it retained that proposed weighting in the final standard published in 1988.[7] The Committee noted that countries could choose to apply low, rather than zero, risk weights to such securities, which could increase with the security’s maturity. Because the standard was explicitly a minimum requirement, including the option to impose a tougher requirement seems likely to have been a rhetorical flourish to paper over disagreement across the member countries.

Indeed, the United States exercised the option in its proposed implementation of the Basel standard. When the Fed proposed the new capital requirement, Treasury securities with remaining maturities of 91 days or less were to receive a zero risk weight, while those with longer maturities were to receive a 10 percent risk weight.[8] However, when the rule was finalized the following year, the risk weight on all Treasuries, regardless of maturity, was set to zero.[9] American Banker wrote at the time that Fed Chair Alan Greenspan had wanted to retain the positive risk-weight on longer-term Treasury securities but Comptroller Robert Clarke argued that the securities carry no risk to banks and so should get a zero risk weight.[10]

In the final rule, the Board stated that commenters had objected to the proposed treatment for two reasons. First, it did not consider the interest rate risk of all assets, liabilities and off-balance-sheet items. Second, it would put the commenters at a competitive disadvantage because most G-10 countries intended to assign a zero weight to all domestic central government securities regardless of maturity.

The Board of Governors recognized that interest rate risk had been dropped. “Assigning long-term direct government obligations to the zero percent risk category differs from past Board proposals, and should not be interpreted as suggesting that the holding of such instruments involves little or no risk.” The Board stated that the leverage ratio requirement will ensure that banks fund Treasuries of all maturities with some equity. It also stated that “…examiners will continue to carefully scrutinize banking organizations’ interest rate exposure carefully and require that institutions with undue levels of interest rate risk strengthen their capital positions even though they may meet the minimum capital standards.”


[1] The 1956 version of the ABC form is available here; for further discussion of form ABC, see BPI note “Rummaging through the Fed archives: When capital and liquidity regulations were integrated,” October 12, 2021.

[2] See the Federal Reserve History note “Bank Capital Standards” for a concise and helpful discussion.

[3] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1986-01-31/pdf/FR-1986-01-31.pdf

[4] https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/title/federal-reserve-bank-new-york-circulars-466/10155-proposed-risk-based-capital-framework-527874

[5] Risk weights cannot be directly compared across different proposals because the level of the requirement and the definition of capital can be different.

[6] https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs03a.pdf

[7] https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs04a.pdf

[8] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1988-03-15/pdf/FR-1988-03-15.pdf p. 8553

[9] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1989-01-27/pdf/FR-1989-01-27.pdf p. 4186, p. 4190

[10] “Impact of Risk-Based Capital Rules to Be Eased Longer-Term Treasury Securities’ 10% Risk Weighting to

Be Eliminated,” American Banker, October 28, 1988.