The Clearing House (TCH) has filed an unsolicited comment letter identifying significant analytical, policy and practical problems that strongly caution against any incorporation of the capital surcharge for U.S. GSIBs into CCAR. TCH argues that these issues are compounded by what appear to be significant limitations and weaknesses in the methodological framework used to calibrate the FRB’s GSIB surcharge rule (which has never been subject to public comment). Specifically, TCH argues that: (i) incorporating the GSIB surcharge into CCAR would undermine its credibility and integrity as a stress test; (ii) CCAR is already designed to capture risks that are unique to GSIBs; (iii) weaknesses and limitations of the FRB’s methodology for calibrating the GSIB surcharge make any incorporation of the surcharge into CCAR particularly inappropriate; and (iv) failure of the GSIB surcharge rule to account for continuing regulatory developments that have substantially decreased the systemic risk of GSIBs makes its calibration increasingly inaccurate and overstated. TCH also identifies market consequences with increasing the required post-stress capital amounts under CCAR by some or all of the GSIB surcharge.
You Might Also Be Interested In...
Bank Capital and Stress Testing Goldilocks and the Fourth Way: Assessing Credit Risk for Capital Purposes
Bank Capital and Stress Testing Regulators Ask Banks To Assess Climate-Related Risks From Largest Counterparties, but Data Gaps Persist
Bank Activities and Structure Remarks by John Court at the Virginia Law and Business Review 2021 Symposium
Bank Capital and Stress Testing Reserve Balances, Noninterest Expenses, and Bank Performance in the Stress Tests
More Posts by This Author
FinTech & Innovation Central Bank Digital Currencies: Costs, Benefits and Major Implications for the U.S. Economic System
Consumer Affairs The CFPB Must Collect Small Business Lending Data from All Financial Institutions to Further Fair Lending Objectives
AML, Bank Secrecy Act and Sanctions BPI Calls for 2021 Interagency Guidance To Be Implemented Into Exam Practices
FinTech & Innovation BPI Statement in Advance of HFSC Task Force Hearing on Central Bank Digital Currency
Bank Activities and Structure When Consistency is Not Foolish: A More Sensible Approach To Granting Fed Accounts and Paying Interest on Reserves