Washington, D.C. — The FDIC’s recent proposal to amend its regulations under the Change in Bank Control Act (CBCA) would exceed the agency’s statutory authority and create unnecessary complexity in how the government reviews investments in banks, BPI said in a comment letter filed late yesterday. The FDIC should withdraw the proposal.
“The FDIC aims to regulate 10% investments by index funds in a number of bank holding companies already subject to Federal Reserve scrutiny, but this proposal is a solution in search of a problem. It’s unclear why the agency sees index funds as a threat justifying an unnecessary regulatory requirement when these investors are motivated to prioritize long-term shareholder value, are unable to sell shares quickly as a means of influence and are already restricted from exercising active control of banks. In fact, the proposal may threaten a stable source of bank equity funding and elevate the voting power of activist investors. The FDIC should avoid unintended consequences and abide by the statute.” – Gregg Rozansky, BPI senior vice president and senior associate general counsel
Background: When Congress enacted the CBCA, it empowered the federal banking regulators to vet transactions where a person intends to acquire at least 10% of the voting shares of an insured depository institution, or IDI — the part of a banking organization that has deposit insurance. The CBCA defines “IDI” broadly to include both conventional IDIs, like banks, as well as bank holding companies and divided review of investments in IDIs among the three federal banking agencies. The Federal Reserve is empowered to review 10% investments in Federal Reserve-supervised bank holding companies. But under the FDIC proposal, the FDIC would interject itself into the review process for proposed investments in bank holding companies made by investors such as index mutual funds and exchange traded funds that buy and sell stock to replicate the performance of an index such as the S&P 500 that have grown in popularity in recent years.
The FDIC’s proposal would change its longstanding approach to this law by requiring FDIC approval of a 10% stake in a Federal Reserve-supervised bank holding company that owns an FDIC-supervised state non-member bank thereby introducing scenarios where an investor would need to seek the FDIC’s consent (in addition to the Federal Reserve’s consent) in order to complete an acquisition of voting stock.
- Details of the law: The CBCA requires the submission of a formal written notice to a federal regulator when someone intends to invest above a certain threshold in a bank or bank holding company (i.e., generally, 10%). The question of which federal banking regulator should review and sign off on transactions is also a key detail of the proposal – the law authorizes only a single banking agency to review a change of control of a bank or bank holding company. The FDIC’s proposal would create duplicative requirements that go beyond its CBCA statutory authority.
The FDIC should withdraw the proposal for several reasons:
- The FDIC proposes action that exceeds its statutory authority. The statute grants authority to a single federal banking agency to review a change of control of an IDI —explicitly defined to include both depository institutions and holding companies of depository institutions. The FDIC does not have authority to review investments in the voting stock of holding companies that are already subject to the CBCA jurisdiction of the Federal Reserve.
- The FDIC’s position contradicts the statute’s text, structure, and history, as well as common sense, and is inconsistent with longstanding interagency practice in implementing the CBCA, which has never required duplicate review of a single transaction by multiple federal banking agencies.
- The FDIC has not articulated a practical benefit to be derived from its novel extension of CBCA jurisdiction to investments in bank holding company voting stock, but the harms to banks are clear. They include threats of introducing redundant agency action, the potential for inconsistent applications of the same statutory standard to the same transaction and creating uncertainty in the equity markets for certain banks, including their potential loss of access to the capital markets and market liquidity on normal terms.
Bottom line: The FDIC’s proposal would create confusion, duplicate requirements, exceed its statutory authority and depart from longstanding legal precedent. On changes in bank control, agencies should stay in their lanes and stick to the statute.
###
About Bank Policy Institute.
The Bank Policy Institute is a nonpartisan public policy, research and advocacy group that represents universal banks, regional banks and the major foreign banks doing business in the United States. The Institute produces academic research and analysis on regulatory and monetary policy topics, analyzes and comments on proposed regulations, and represents the financial services industry with respect to cybersecurity, fraud, and other information security issues.
Media Contacts
Tara Payne, Bank Policy Institute, tara.payne@bpi.com
