Redundant, Costly and Inaccurate: The U.S. Bank Liquidity Regime Needs a Rethink
The U.S. bank liquidity framework is overly complex, redundant and prone to inaccurate estimates, a new BPI blog post explains. The expansion of liquidity requirements prompted by the Global Financial Crisis is now due for a re-evaluation.
- State of play: The current liquidity framework epitomizes the post-crisis approach of “everything everywhere all at once”, with five key components: ongoing examination and horizontal reviews; two numerical requirements based on international standards; internal stress testing requirements; and resolution and recovery requirements.
- Why it matters: The overlapping regime forces banks to stockpile liquid assets rather than making loans. This tradeoff reduces economic output and employment. Sensible reforms would promote lending and support economic growth while maintaining a robust and liquid banking system.
- Problems and solutions: The note explains the components of the current framework and how they are complex, redundant, inaccurate and costly, and outlines potential improvements. A key necessary change is that the entire framework should recognize the liquidity value of having banks operationally ready with collateral prepositioned at the discount window.
Five Key Things
1. Banks Urge Court to Vacate CFPB’s Section 1033 Rule
The Bank Policy Institute, Forcht Bank and the Kentucky Bankers Association filed a motion on Friday with the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky making their case for why the CFPB’s Section 1033 is unlawful and should be vacated — an admission that the CFPB itself made in a filing with the Court late last week.
In the motion, the plaintiffs wrote:
“This case involves an agency that drastically overstepped its statutory authority, injected itself into a well-functioning ecosystem that was thriving under private industry initiatives, and installed a burdensome, irrational and risky regulatory framework in its place. That regime is unlawful many times over.”
The plaintiffs highlighted a robust and competitive data-sharing environment that already exists in the U.S., irrespective of the Section 1033 rule. This ecosystem enables hundreds of millions of consumers to safely share their data, driven in large part by investments by banks. However, the rule could significantly disrupt the existing ecosystem and place sensitive consumer financial data at risk:
“Banks welcome the new opportunities to serve their customers that open banking has created. But there are obvious risks. Consumer financial data can be extremely damaging in the wrong hands, especially if it can be used to move money out of consumers’ accounts. As a matter of both business necessity and regulatory obligation, banks place the highest priority on protecting their customers’ financial information. … [T]he Rule’s framework places customers’ most sensitive financial data at risk, while simultaneously handcuffing banks in their ability to mitigate that risk and assuming no role for the Bureau itself in policing it.”
2. Bessent: SLR Update Could Come in Summer
The banking agencies are “moving along very quickly” on revisions to the supplementary leverage ratio, a constraint on banks’ ability to intermediate in the Treasury market, said Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent in a Bloomberg interview this week. “I would think we could see something on that over the summer,” Bessent said. He said the action could have a significant impact on Treasury yields, “because banks are being penalized for holding Treasuries.”
- Context: Several current and former policymakers and experts have made connections between banks’ constrained Treasury market-making capacity and the supplementary leverage ratio, noting that SLR reform could ease pressures on Treasury market liquidity. In 2023 comments, former Federal Reserve Governor Daniel Tarullo said: “[I]t would be ill-advised not to recognize the changes in Treasury markets, beginning with their increased size because of fiscal policy. The modifications of capital regulation, especially the eSLR, suggested here should ease (though not eliminate) constraints on banks holding and trading Treasuries without endangering the foundations of the post-GFC reforms.”
- FDIC: In addition, this week, Acting FDIC Chair Travis Hill expressed hope that “we will have a proposal to issue in the relatively near future,” Hill said, noting the goal to address concerns about the rule’s effect on “low-risk, low-margin businesses like Treasury market intermediation.”
3. FRBNY Paper: Credit Scores, Not Socioeconomic Status, Predict Overdraft Fees
A Federal Reserve Bank of New York paper published this week, titled “Who’s Paying Those Overdraft Fees?”, sought to understand key factors behind frequent overdrafts by surveying 1,000 households about their overdraft activity. The survey found that, when considering credit scores along with respondents’ socioeconomic traits, only credit scores predict overdrafts. While overdraft activity tends to be higher among lower-income, Black and Hispanic households, the survey’s findings paint a more complete picture of overdrafts beyond socioeconomic profile. According to Barclays bank analyst Jason Goldberg: “It would be more precise to say that overdraft fees are paid disproportionately by more credit constrained individuals, some of whom happen to be lower-income, Black, or Hispanic. In other words, credit risk, not socioeconomics, is the primary predictor of overdrafts.”
4. Traversing the Pond
Here’s what’s new in international banking policy.
- Trading rules delayed: The European Union will delay the application of new market risk capital requirements for banks amid competitive concerns and uncertainty over the U.S. rollout of Basel III Endgame, according to Bloomberg. The Fundamental Review of the Trading Book regulation will be delayed by one year to the beginning of 2027. Whether the rule will also be amended at some point has been the subject of media speculation given the recent Commission consultation on this.
- Sifting through layers: The European Commission is considering delaying non-essential policy measures affecting the financial sector, with the goal of simplification, according to Risk. The EC is sifting through hundreds of “delegated acts” – peripheral measures that amend or augment EU legislation – to identify ones that may be delayed because they are not critical to the functioning of primary legislation. These supplementary measures, which support, supplement and clarify the Level 1 text to create a framework, have significantly increased in volume in recent years.
- UK crypto proposals: The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority this week published two consultation papers seeking public input on crypto proposals. One consultation sets out proposed prudential rules and guidance for stablecoin issuance and the custody of certain cryptoassets. The other seeks input on rules and guidance for issuing stablecoins and custodying them.
5. The Crypto Ledger
Here’s the latest in crypto.
- Market structure bill: House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill (R-AR) introduced an updated version of crypto market structure legislation this week. The bill, known as the CLARITY Act, would amend securities laws to grant new authority over crypto oversight to the CFTC, would allow firms to self-custody digital assets and would prohibit any future attempts to impose the requirements of the now-repealed SAB 121.
- ‘Wrench attack’ arrest: A third suspect accused of kidnapping and torturing an Italian crypto investor to steal his Bitcoin has been arrested in New York. The suspect, William Duplessie, as well as alleged accomplices, is accused of holding Michael Valentino Teofrasto Carturan captive in a New York City townhouse and torturing him to gain access to a digital wallet. Carturan escaped and alerted a police officer. The case is one of the latest so-called “wrench attacks” in which thieves use violence and intimidation to access crypto holders’ assets.
- Avoid distractions: Rep. Bryan Steil (R-WI) urged fellow lawmakers not to attach “non-germane items” to stablecoin legislation under consideration. “We have to restrain ourselves from that instinct and attempt by our colleagues — both sides of the aisle,” Steil said at a digital assets conference this week.
Member News
Regions Announces Disaster-Recovery Grants for Areas Affected by Recent Midwestern Storms
Regions Foundation, a nonprofit primarily funded by Regions Bank, recently announced a series of grants totaling $60,000 to support disaster recovery following a deadly tornado affecting St. Louis and surrounding communities on May 16. The funding will support recovery and relief efforts such as food, shelter and cleanup needs.
