Media Reports Suggest Very Serious Cyber Security Issue at OCC
After the OCC last week disclosed a hack to its systems, details emerging in media reports depict a series of lapses and an extended intrusion into sensitive bank data.
- Timeline: The intrusion began in May 2023 and lasted until early 2025, about a year and a half. Over 150,000 emails from the accounts of 100 OCC officials were compromised. It is presumed that any attachments were also viewed. Many of these emails contained highly sensitive information about the financial condition of federally regulated banks.
- Suspected cause: The breach was facilitated by the compromise of an administrative account with broad access, highlighting the risk of overprivileged accounts lacking proper segmentation and monitoring. In addition, delayed detection of abnormal activity seems to indicate lapses in real-time security monitoring and logging.
- Detection: The breach was detected not by the OCC but by Microsoft, which notified the agency in February 2025 about unusual network behavior.
- ‘Demonstrable harm’: “The analysis concluded that the highly sensitive bank information contained in the emails and attachments is likely to result in demonstrable harm to public confidence,” OCC Chief Information Officer Kristen Baldwin wrote in a draft letter to Congress reported by Bloomberg News.
- Banks taking preventative measures: Several banks have opted to limit information sharing with the OCC until they can confirm their data is safe.
- Reorg announcement: The OCC on Wednesday announced changes to its organizational structure, including elevating an Information Technology and Security senior deputy comptroller position to the agency’s executive team. The OCC also combined its Midsize and Community Bank Supervision and Large Bank Supervision departments into a new Bank Supervision and Examination division.
Five Key Things
1. BPI Response to Federal Reserve’s Proposal to Average Stress Test Results
The Federal Reserve issued a proposed rule this week, which includes averaging of stress test results — beginning with the 2025 stress testing cycle — a delay of the annual effective date of the stress capital buffer to give more time for banks to adjust to the new requirement and an expansion of the data collection to improve the modeling of bank net revenues. BPI President and CEO Greg Baer responded to the announcement shortly after its release on Thursday:
Today’s proposal to suppress spurious volatility in stress capital charges through averaging is one part of the Federal Reserve’s promised reforms to its stress testing framework. In its release, the Federal Reserve commits to disclosure of the models that calculate capital depletion under the stress test as well as the scenarios that form the basis of the test. We look forward to those steps, which are required to meet the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act.
2. Treasury Officials Eye SLR Changes
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Deputy Secretary Michael Faulkender said federal policymakers are considering changes to the supplementary leverage ratio, a capital measure with major implications for banks’ Treasury market-making capacity. “We are investigating it, and we are having conversations about it,” Faulkender said of SLR changes at a recent event. Bessent also said recently that policymakers are hard at work on an SLR solution. “The question that we continue to ask ourselves is, in times of market volatility, or if there were to be a stress event, do we have adequate liquidity coming into the system,” Faulkender said this week. “So to the extent that the SLR is binding … during times of stress unnecessarily, are there ways for us to increase the capacity of the bond market to handle large volume days?” In addition, Bessent said this week that Treasury has “a big toolkit that we can roll out” in bond market turmoil.
- What experts are saying: BPI published a fact sheet this week outlining what key policymakers are saying about the SLR. Read it here.
- Liang’s view: Nellie Liang, former Treasury Under Secretary for Domestic Finance, recommended a multifaceted solution to problems in the U.S. Treasury market in a recent analysis. Liang, now a senior Brookings Institution fellow, outlined recent turbulence in the Treasury market, acknowledged factors straining the market such as bank capacity constraints due to capital regulation and called for various policy reforms. She urged policymakers not to further delay the effective dates for an SEC rule on central clearing, modify the supplementary leverage ratio and prevent excessive leverage and rapid forced Treasury sales. She expressed the view that a multi-layered solution is necessary: “Prudent changes to the SLR would not on its own significantly improve intermediation and strengthen resilience in stress periods, especially as the amount of Treasury debt continues to grow,” she said. “Central clearing as well as incentives from the SRF are needed to increase intermediation capacity, and stronger rules and supervision to reduce liquidity mismatch and leverage of investors also are needed.”
3. The Most Damaging ‘Guidance’ in Banking
The federal banking agencies’ Model Risk Management Guidance is a prime example of a policy that should be reconsidered as the administration seeks to rationalize regulation and promote economic growth. The guidance, which is being enforced illegally, dictates how banks should validate and document the models they use across all aspects of their operations. It should be withdrawn and reproposed for public comment.
- Why it matters: The guidance has impeded bank innovation, including effective use of AI. It has created a sprawling compliance bureaucracy and has disrupted bank operations. It also has never been updated to reflect advancements in technology since its adoption over a decade ago.
- Bottom line: There is a legitimate role for bank examiners to play in evaluating how banks manage some of their models. Clear guidance could help ensure consistency in that oversight. But the scope of such guidance should be limited to models producing outcomes material to the bank’s condition or financial reporting, and it should allow banks room to pursue innovation in modeling.
4. BPI Supports Reauthorization of Cyber Threat Information Sharing Law
Heather Hogsett, BPI senior vice president and deputy head of BITS — BPI’s technology policy division — issued a statement this week in support of legislation to reauthorize the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act (CISA 2015), before it expires on Sept. 30, 2025:
The Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act has helped safeguard the financial system for over 10 years by enabling banks to share timely information to identify and defend against cyber threats. This law appropriately balances privacy and security and letting it lapse could make America’s financial system more vulnerable to emerging cyber risks. We’re grateful to Senators Gary Peters and Mike Rounds for recognizing these risks and advancing this essential, common-sense legislation.
5. Vought Urges Rollback of ‘Weaponized’ CFPB Guidance
Acting CFPB Director Russell Vought directed bureau staff to undertake a comprehensive review of CFPB guidance, which he said has been “weaponized” as backdoor regulation beyond the agency’s statutory limits. Under former CFPB Director Rohit Chopra, the agency issued frequent bulletins, circulars, advisory materials and other documents that fell short of rulemaking but were used to police financial firms’ behavior. In recent memos, Vought said staff “may not issue guidance documents that purport to create rights or obligations binding on persons or entities outside the bureau” and should rescind guidance that “has unlawfully regulated private parties.”
In Case You Missed It
BPI’s Baer on Supervision: All Trees, No Forest
BPI President and CEO Greg Baer participated this week in a panel discussion at a George Mason University event titled “The Great Debate: How to Modernize Financial Regulation and Create Economic Stability in a Digital Age.” The panel’s title was “Why Don’t We See Financial Sector Crises Coming & How Do We Make Supervision Work Better?
Keynote remarks were delivered by Elizabeth McCaul who recently stepped down as a member of the European Central Bank’s Supervisory Board. McCaul focused her remarks on the need for simplification while endorsing the status quo for regulation and supervision, describing the benefits of high capital requirements and an empowered examination focused on all areas of bank operations.
The panel also featured Yale Professor Gary Gorton and Mises Institute Senior Fellow Alex Pollock, who critiqued the inability of regulators to differentiate between minor risks and systemic threats.
- Misguided focus: Baer emphasized how bank examiners are focusing on tangential issues, rather than material risks. He gave context for this shift by describing the regulatory changes put in place after the Global Financial Crisis, namely more stringent capital and liquidity requirements and a revamp of how large banks’ securities business lines are funded. “We did not have a global financial crisis because of vendor management or because IT systems weren’t sufficiently up to date, or any number of operational issues that are now the primary focus of our supervisory regime,” he said. “It’s now trees, not forest.” Silicon Valley Bank’s supervision exemplified this loss of focus on core risks, Baer said.
- Other topics: Other issues discussed included the rise of private credit, the vulnerabilities of macroprudential policy, the optimal design of a regulatory system, regulatory complexity and which risks warrant the greatest concern from regulators.
BPI Statement on Indefensible CFPB Credit Card Late Fee Rule
Paige Pidano Paridon, BPI SVP, senior associate general counsel and co-head of regulatory affairs, issued a statement this week in response to a decision by a U.S. District Court to vacate the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s credit card late fee rule:
“We appreciate that the current CFPB recognizes the Biden Administration’s late fee rule is deeply flawed and indefensible. Late fees are already heavily regulated, fully transparent and play a key role in encouraging on-time payments and responsible borrowing. If implemented, this rule would have disrupted the highly competitive credit card market, driven up the cost of loans and limited access to credit.”
The Crypto Ledger
Here’s what’s new in crypto.
- Anchorage: Crypto firm Anchorage is under U.S. Department of Homeland Security investigation, according to media reports. Anchorage holds a conditional charter from the OCC. The firm is being probed by a DHS task force focused on financial crimes and anti-money laundering. Anchorage was subject to an OCC consent order regarding its BSA/AML practices.
- Temporary relief: SEC Acting Chair Mark Uyeda said late last week that the agency may consider granting crypto firms “conditional exemptive relief” while regulators craft a long-term framework to oversee digital assets markets. Such relief would pave the way for innovation in blockchain technology, he said.
Bank of England Proposes to Increase Buffer Thresholds in Key Capital Measure
The Bank of England recently proposed to update the threshold for its O-SII buffer (other systemically important institutions) to account for economic growth in the UK. “In light of its assessment, the FPC proposes to increase O-SII buffer thresholds based on the 20% cumulative growth in nominal GDP between 2019 and 2023 to ensure the framework reflects the original risk appetite of the Committee,” the BoE said in a consultation document, referring to the Financial Policy Committee, a BoE body in charge of monitoring systemic risks. The BoE acknowledged the impacts of recent economic growth on financial sector activities. “If the nominal thresholds remain unchanged, more firms would be captured under the framework over time, and those already captured would move into higher buffer rate buckets, with those changes not necessarily reflecting an increase in firms’ potential to disrupt the credit supply,” the BoE said. “Thus, updating the thresholds supports the efficient allocation of capital and supports lending to the real economy, in line with the FPC’s secondary objective to support the Government’s economic policy.” Separately, BPI has called on U.S. banking agencies to adjust tailoring thresholds to account for economic growth since 2019.
Goldman Sachs’ Solomon Calls for SLR Reform
Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon emphasized the need for supplementary leverage ratio reform in comments this week. “SLR relief would have a benefit to Treasury markets,” Solomon said. “It’s an important structural reform.”
Bank Regulators Approve Capital One, Discover Merger
The Federal Reserve and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency approved the Capital One and Discover merger on Friday following an extensive review process that began in March 2024. The deal is expected to close on May 18, 2025. As part of the announcement, Capital One also committed to resolving regulatory deficiencies at Discover related to interchange fees.
