To Whom It May Concern:
The Bank Policy Institute[1] welcomes the opportunity to respond to the joint notice and request for comment by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System regarding revisions to the Financial Statements of Foreign Subsidiaries of U.S. Banking Organizations (FR 2314) and the Financial Statements of U.S. Nonbank Subsidiaries of U.S. Holding Companies (FR Y-11).[2] BPI is supportive of the proposed revisions to the FR Y-11 and FR 2314 that would align the reporting of modifications to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty (MBEFD) to U.S. GAAP. We are also supportive of using the FR 2314 and FFIEC 030 to collect data currently collected in the FR 2502q. However, we have concerns that the current proposal would serve to significantly increase the burden on covered entities both for initial implementation and on an ongoing basis, as opposed to the FFIEC 030 proposal’s determination that shifting the FR 2502q items to these forms “would reduce overall respondent burden.”[3]
Our comments herein are aimed at aligning the scope of entities that would be required to provide the proposed new items on Schedule BS-Q of the FR 2314 with those currently subject to reporting on the FR 2502q and seeking clarifications on certain proposed revisions to the FR Y-11 and FR 2314. Additionally, given the significance of the changes required and the operational challenges presented, to the extent the Federal Reserve implements the proposed changes and maintains the proposed reporting scope, we respectfully request a delayed effective date of at least four quarters following the issuance of final forms and instructions. If the scope of respondents for proposed FR 2314 Schedule BS-Q were to be limited to those who meet the current requirements for reporting on the FR 2502q, firms would only need two additional quarters following issuance of final documentation to implement these revisions.
I. The proposed revisions to replace TDRs with MBEFDs are properly aligned with current U.S. GAAP reporting and should be finalized as proposed.
ASU 2022-02 eliminated the recognition and measurement guidance for TDRs for institutions that have adopted CECL and introduced new disclosure requirements for MBEFDs.[4] Prior to the adoption of CECL, a TDR had a different credit loss recognition measurement than other loans; however, under CECL, all loans are measured under a lifetime loss recognition model and therefore separate TDR accounting is no longer needed. The new FASB standard, established in ASU 2022-02, requires the disclosure of the type and financial effect of MBEFDs for the current reporting period, and receivable performance in the 12 months following a modification.[5] We are supportive of the Federal Reserve’s efforts in this proposal to “revise the FR 2314 and FR Y-11 forms and instructions to be consistent with adopted changes to U.S. generally accepted accounting principles related to troubled debt restructurings”.[6]
BPI has previously commented several times on the importance of affirming the U.S. GAAP standard 12-month lookback period for the reporting of MBEFDs to provide proper insight into the risk profile of existing MBEFDs in accordance with how banks have been managing MBEFDs to date.[7] In Schedule BS-A line item 7(d), the Federal Reserve states that “modified loans reported in this schedule should meet the definition of loan modifications to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty, as described in ASU 2022-02, which includes only those modifications which occurred in the previous 12 months.”[8] We commend the Federal Reserve for properly aligning the reporting standard to U.S. GAAP and current firm practices, which will allow for the collection of relevant information without undue regulatory reporting burden to institutions. Further, as previously stated, we would encourage the Federal Reserve to work with the other agencies to implement this 12-month lookback standard on all applicable reporting forms, including the Call Report.
To read the full comment letter, please click here, or click on the download button below.
[1] The Bank Policy Institute is a nonpartisan public policy, research and advocacy group that represents universal banks, regional banks, and the major foreign banks doing business in the United States. The Institute produces academic research and analysis on regulatory and monetary policy topics, analyzes and comments on proposed regulations, and represents the financial services industry with respect to cybersecurity, fraud, and other information security issues.
[2] 89 Fed. Reg. 48639.
[3] 89 Fed. Reg. 3708.
[4] FASB, Accounting Standards Update No. 2022-02, available at
https://www.fasb.org/Page/ShowPdf?path=ASU+2022-02.pdf.
[5] Id. at 12.
[6] Supra note 2.
[7] BPI, Call Report and FFIEC 002 Revisions OMB Control No: OCC 1557-0081, FRB 7100-0036,
FDIC 3064-0052 and FR Y-9 Report Revisions OMB Control No: 7100-0128, available at https://bpi.com/bpi-comments-on-banking-agencies-proposed-revisions-to-call-reports-and-fr-y-9/
BPI, Call Report and FFIEC 002 Revisions; OMB Control No: OCC 1557-0081, FRB 7100-0036, FDIC
3064-0052, FFIEC 7100–0032, available at https://bpi.com/bpi-recommends-call-report-changes-to-address-troubled-debt-restructuring/
See letter titled Reporting of MBEFD for Q1 2024 Call Reports and FR Y-9C from BPI dated April 30,2024.
[8] Federal Reserve, Proposed FR 2314 Instructions, available at https://www.federalreserve.gov/apps/reportingforms/Report/Index/FR_2314FR_2314S
